Sigma Quattro DP2 & Merrill Revisited

The last time I had a Quattro it lasted one week. A combination of poor results and immature SPP led me to the conclusion that the camera was just not ready, or perhaps that there was a more fundamental issue with the new sensor design when compared to that bit of magic at the heart of the Merrill.

Then those Sigma people tempted me to give the Quattro a second try,  with updated firmware and SPP,  and I found myself once again comparing the Merrill and the Quattro, re-shooting some of the original images and re-processing others using SPP 6.0.6.

Quatto DP2 & Merrill DP3 Leeds Panoramic (Re-shot) Ok, so this is an unfair comparison given the difference in reach between the 50mm Merrill and 30mm Quattro, and that zooming with my feet would have got me wet, but this time around I see a much more acceptable rendition from the Quattro.

Leeds Panoramic | Quattro DP2
Leeds Panoramic | Quattro DP2
Leeds Panoramic | Merrill DP3
Leeds Panoramic | Merrill DP3

(note that the white balance for the Quattro images are different between the pano above and detail below – “as shot” changed to “auto”)

Leeds Panorama - Quattro & DP3 Detail
Leeds Panorama – Quattro & DP3 Detail
Leeds Panorama - Quattro & DP3 Detail
Leeds Panorama – Quattro & DP3 Detail
Leeds Panorama - Quattro & DP3 Detail
Leeds Panorama – Quattro & DP3 Detail

Leeds Red Brick (New Shots)

Red Brick | Merrill DP3
Red Brick | Merrill DP3
Red Brick | Quattro DP2
Red Brick | Quattro DP2
Leeds Red Brick Detail 1
Leeds Red Brick Detail 1
Leeds Red Brick Detail 2
Leeds Red Brick Detail 2

Clock & Green (Re-shot)

Clock & Green | Merrill DP3
Clock & Green | Merrill DP3
Clock & Green | Quattro DP2
Clock & Green | Quattro DP2
Clocks & Green - Brown Leaf
Clocks & Green – Brown Leaf
Clocks & Green - Leaf
Clocks & Green – Leaf
Clocks & Green - Spider Web
Clocks & Green – Spider Web

Check out the spiders web as it extends over the clock dial on the Merrill. Try as I might I could not recreate this white over white contrast with the Quattro!

Ossett War Memorial

Ossett War Memorial | Quattro DP2
Ossett War Memorial | Quattro DP2
Ossett War Memorial B&W | Merrill DP3
Ossett War Memorial B&W | Merrill DP3

Temple of the Four Winds 

Temple of the Winds | Sigma Merrill DP3 | www.richardjwalls.com
Temple of the Winds | Sigma Merrill DP3 | http://www.richardjwalls.com
Temple of the Winds | Sigma Quattro DP2 | www.richardjwalls.com
Temple of the Winds | Sigma Quattro DP2 | http://www.richardjwalls.com

So what we have with the Quattro is a camera that undoubtedly represents a step change improvement in terms of usability from the previous generation, and when judged on its own merits produces images of outstanding quality that retain that Foveon look. It’s certainty not a camera to be sniffed at!

But the problem for the Quattro (and for Sigma) is that for loyal Merrill owners it’s nigh on impossible to judge the Quattro on its own merits when the Merrill sets the IQ bar so high. And for those whose need for usability means they are prepared to compromise IQ there’s a myriad of high-end compact cameras out there on the market, let alone DSLRs, that will produce excellent results.

So will I keep the Quattro this time around? I have to admit to being tempted. The IQ is great … the usability is just so much better …. despite the evidence above I’m no pixel peeper and more interested in the overall look … and if I didn’t already own a Merrill … but the trouble is I do …

… I think I need to sleep on it!

http://www.richardjwalls.com

All shots were taken with a tripod and 2-second delay (accept Ossett War Memorial hand held), at ISO100 and F9, in the same lighting conditions (2-3 minutes apart maximum, and an attempt to get the same exposure . All shots were converted to tiff 16 bit in SPP 6.0.5 with luminance noise reduction at the minimum setting; no other processing. All shots adjusted on Lightroom with the same settings – auto white balance, clarity and contrast up, sharpness up. Shadows and highlights adjusted for exposure, and no noise reduction.


3 thoughts on “Sigma Quattro DP2 & Merrill Revisited

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s